The United Kingdom’s skilled worker visa programme, introduced to attract talent across priority sectors, has seen a dramatic surge in applications and arrivals over the past few years. However, a new report from the National Audit Office (NAO) has highlighted serious concerns about the effectiveness of the system, gaps in monitoring, and unintended consequences that could reshape the country’s immigration landscape.
According to the NAO, the number of foreign nationals entering the UK under the Skilled Worker visa scheme has significantly exceeded government forecasts. Between 2020 and 2024, more than 931,000 visas were issued—almost three times the originally anticipated figure of 360,000.
Originally launched to address workforce shortages in key areas such as healthcare, engineering, and IT, the Skilled Worker route has increasingly become a pivotal tool in meeting the UK’s labour market needs. However, a sharp rise in the number of migrants using this route to eventually claim asylum has raised red flags in Westminster and among immigration analysts.
Asylum Claims Spike Among Skilled Workers
One of the most startling revelations in the NAO’s review is the more than 100-fold increase in asylum claims made by skilled workers. In 2022, just 53 individuals on skilled worker visas sought asylum. By October 2024, that number had soared to over 5,300.
Critics argue this trend points to deeper systemic issues. “The asylum claims from visa holders indicate that some migrants may be arriving under the skilled worker scheme with different intentions or are facing unforeseen vulnerabilities once in the UK,” said a senior immigration advisor.
Although asylum remains a legally protected right under international law, the rise in such claims by individuals who entered through a vetted and employer-sponsored route has sparked a debate on policy misuse and gaps in post-entry monitoring.
Also Read:
Tracking Challenges and Data Deficiencies
The Home Office has admitted it lacks clear data on what happens to thousands of skilled workers after their visas expire. While 23% still hold valid visas four years after entry and 15% have secured indefinite leave to remain, the fate of the remaining 62% remains unknown.
The government’s failure to conduct updated exit checks since 2020 has further compounded the problem. “Without timely exit tracking and longitudinal monitoring, the system risks becoming leaky and unaccountable,” said Gareth Davies, head of the NAO. “We need robust data analytics to inform decision-making and policy design.”
Dependants and Long-Term Residency Trends
The skilled worker route has also led to a substantial rise in the number of dependants entering the UK. In 2021, around 55,200 dependants were recorded. By 2023, that figure had surged to 254,100—a 360% increase. The influx of families has placed additional pressure on public services including housing, education, and healthcare.
Additionally, the number of skilled workers transitioning to permanent residency has grown significantly. In 2024 alone, over 44,000 individuals applied for indefinite leave to remain—a steep rise from 25,000 in 2021.
Policy Shifts and Unassessed Impacts
Since its inception, the Skilled Worker visa scheme has undergone numerous changes—some driven by labour shortages, others by political pressure to curb migration. In 2022, for instance, care workers were added to the list of eligible occupations to alleviate the social care staffing crisis. However, just two years later, rules were tightened again, including a controversial ban on bringing dependants, aimed at reducing net migration.
Despite these alterations, the NAO report suggests that many changes were implemented without a thorough evaluation of sector-specific impacts or regional demands. The watchdog warned that such reactive policymaking could undermine the scheme’s original intent.
Calls for Reform and Transparency
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, criticised the lack of inter-departmental coordination and data-driven planning. “It’s deeply concerning that the Home Office does not have a clear grasp on how its visa policies are playing out on the ground,” he said. “This is about more than numbers—it’s about trust in the system.”
The NAO has urged the government to publish a comprehensive evaluation of the Skilled Worker route by mid-2025 and to implement a structured assessment of visa holders’ outcomes post-expiry.
Looking Ahead
As the UK navigates a post-Brexit labour market and intensifies its efforts to strike a balance between economic needs and migration control, the future of the skilled worker visa programme remains central to the national debate.
While the scheme has undeniably helped plug critical workforce gaps, especially in the NHS and tech sector, the growing complexities around visa misuse, data blind spots, and policy swings underscore the need for a more strategic, transparent, and accountable immigration framework.
