Donald Trump has proposed eliminating federal taxes on overtime pay, tips, and Social Security benefits. This policy aims to increase disposable income and stimulate economic growth.
The proposal, reiterated in January 2025, aligns with Trump’s campaign promise to support workers. The plan seeks to provide financial relief while influencing labour market dynamics.
Key Aspects of the Proposal
- Overtime Pay: Workers will keep more of their earnings without federal income tax deductions.
- Tips: Service industry employees, including restaurant staff and gig workers, will retain full gratuities.
- Social Security Benefits: Retirees will no longer pay federal taxes on their Social Security income.
Figure 1: Trump’s Proposal of No TAX on OVERTIME or TIPS
Trump’s campaign highlights these measures as a strategy to improve financial conditions for millions of workers.
Overtime Pay: Current Tax Structure and Proposed Changes
Overtime pay is currently subject to federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare deductions. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) mandates time-and-a-half pay for hours beyond 40 per week.
- 8% of hourly workers and 4% of salaried employees work overtime regularly.
- An additional 4% of hourly workers and 1% of salaried employees do so occasionally.
Trump argues that eliminating taxes on overtime earnings will encourage employees to work extra hours. The policy also aims to help businesses fill labour shortages without increasing base wages.
Economic Considerations and Potential Revenue Impact
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that eliminating taxes on overtime could reduce federal revenue by $1.7 trillion between 2026 and 2035.
- Supporters believe the policy will increase workforce participation and consumer spending.
- Critics warn that revenue loss could impact federal programs and long-term economic stability.
- The Tax Foundation cautions that increased overtime work may raise employer labour costs.
Also Read: Joann, 80-Year-Old Fabric and Crafts Retailer, to Close All Stores
Employers may need to reassess workforce strategies to balance costs and productivity under the proposed tax exemption.
No-Tax-On-Tips: Implications for Service Industry Workers
Trump first announced his no-tax-on-tips plan in June 2024. He emphasised that tips belong fully to workers, regardless of their occupation.
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that 2.24 million restaurant servers depend on tips for income. Current tax laws treat tips as wages if they exceed $20 per month from a single job.
Under the proposal:
- Employees will no longer report tips as taxable income.
- Employers will not withhold income taxes or pay payroll taxes on reported tips.
- The hospitality industry could see increased earnings for workers and shifts in compensation structures.
Industry Reactions to Tip Tax Changes
Business owners and labour representatives have expressed mixed reactions.
Ryan Hughes-Svab, co-owner of The Misfit Lou restaurant, highlighted potential benefits and risks.
“I think it could benefit a lot of people,” Hughes-Svab told USA Today. “But I also do think when you look at the negative side of it, there could be some of these repercussions.”
Ted Pappageorge, Culinary Union secretary-treasurer, linked the proposal to broader economic concerns.
“Eliminating taxes on tips and ending the $2.13 sub-minimum wage, along with going after big corporations’ price gouging on food, gas, and housing, must be part of an overall programme to tackle the high cost of living for working families,” Pappageorge said in a statement.
The impact on restaurant pricing, payroll management, and employee compensation remains a key consideration for business owners.
No-Tax-On-Social-Security: Retirement Income Adjustments
Trump pledged to eliminate taxes on Social Security benefits. He stated, “SENIORS SHOULD NOT PAY TAX ON SOCIAL SECURITY!” on Truth Social in July 2024.
Under current laws:
- Social Security benefits are taxable if an individual earns over $25,000 annually.
- Joint filers face taxation if household earnings exceed $32,000 per year.
The Social Security Administration has warned that removing these taxes could impact program solvency. Estimates indicate the system could reach insolvency by 2033, two years earlier than current projections.
Business and Workforce Implications of the Proposals
Businesses across multiple sectors may need to adjust financial planning if these tax exemptions take effect.
Workforce and Payroll Management:
- HR departments may see increased employee demand for overtime shifts.
- Employers may revise scheduling policies to prevent burnout and maintain productivity.
- Companies could restructure compensation plans to balance exempt and non-exempt worker concerns.
Labour Market Adjustments:
- Tax-free overtime may make extra shifts more attractive, reducing the need for temporary workers.
- Businesses could face cost increases due to changes in worker compensation expectations.
- Service industry employers may reassess base pay rates to accommodate new tip tax rules.
Economic Effects on Consumer Spending:
- Increased take-home pay could drive higher consumer spending.
- Businesses may see shifts in purchasing trends based on changes in disposable income.
Future Legislative Considerations
The proposals require Congressional approval before implementation. Economic analysts predict extensive debates over federal revenue implications and funding adjustments.
Trump reiterated his commitment to tax exemptions on overtime, tips, and Social Security in January 2025. The policy’s long-term economic impact will depend on legislative developments and business sector responses.
