D.K. Metcalf’s new contract puts pressure on the Steelers to decide George Pickens’ future—extend, trade, or let him play out his final season.
The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at a crossroads this offseason, following the high-profile contract extension handed to newly acquired wide receiver D.K. Metcalf. The four-year deal, with a staggering new-money average of $33 million annually, firmly positions Metcalf as the centerpiece of the Steelers’ aerial attack. But as the spotlight shifts to Metcalf, the question looms large: what now for George Pickens?
Pickens, who was once considered a rising star in Pittsburgh’s receiving corps, enters the final year of his rookie contract with a base salary of just $3.4 million—a fraction of what Metcalf will now earn. The disparity in pay underscores a shift in priorities within the Steelers organization and raises serious doubts about Pickens’ long-term future with the franchise.
A Frustrated Star on the Sidelines?
Pickens’ frustrations have not exactly been kept under wraps. After the Steelers’ disappointing playoff exit at the hands of the Baltimore Ravens, he was openly critical of the offensive scheme and his role within it. His candid comments sparked speculation that his relationship with the coaching staff may have grown strained.
Now, with the arrival of Metcalf—a more physical, explosive receiver with a proven track record—it’s hard to imagine Pickens getting the kind of target share he would need to prove himself as a WR1. In fact, some analysts argue that Metcalf’s presence could significantly diminish Pickens’ value, both on the field and at the negotiation table.
Trade Winds Gaining Strength
Given the circumstances, trade rumors are swirling. Several teams in need of a young, athletic receiver are reportedly monitoring Pickens’ situation closely. While the Steelers have not officially placed him on the trade block, multiple league sources suggest that exploratory conversations have taken place.
Also Read: Australian Stocks Rebound Amid Global Uncertainty
“Pickens is a talented player who just needs the right system,” one NFC executive said anonymously. “If Pittsburgh isn’t going to pay him or feature him, plenty of other teams will.”
The potential suitors include teams like the New England Patriots, Carolina Panthers, and Arizona Cardinals—all of whom are looking to boost their receiving depth heading into the 2025 season.
Steelers’ Development Pipeline Still Strong
Another factor complicating Pickens’ outlook is the Steelers’ well-earned reputation for identifying and developing wide receiver talent. From Antonio Brown and JuJu Smith-Schuster to Diontae Johnson and now Pickens, Pittsburgh has consistently unearthed stars from the draft. With that history, the front office may be inclined to once again dip into the draft pool rather than allocate big dollars to another receiver.
Steelers General Manager Omar Khan and Head Coach Mike Tomlin have long favored maintaining financial flexibility, especially when it comes to non-quarterback skill positions. Signing Metcalf may have been the exception—an aggressive move to boost the offense—but it’s unlikely they’ll follow it with another major investment in the same position.
Locker Room Dynamics and the No. 14 Jersey
Interestingly, Metcalf’s arrival has also brought a bit of light-hearted speculation about jersey numbers. Currently, Pickens wears No. 14—the same number Metcalf donned in Seattle. While it’s unclear whether Metcalf will request a change, some fans have joked that this might be the clearest sign yet that Pickens’ days in Pittsburgh are numbered.
But beyond jersey logistics, there’s a bigger issue at play: locker room dynamics. If Pickens remains on the roster but feels marginalized in the offense, it could become a distraction—a risk the Steelers might not be willing to take.
A Prove-It Year—or a New Beginning?
The Steelers could choose to retain Pickens for one more season, allowing him to play out his rookie contract before making a final decision. This would give the team depth and flexibility, while also allowing Pickens to showcase his skills in hopes of landing a lucrative deal—either in Pittsburgh or elsewhere.
However, if Metcalf dominates the target share and Pickens sees limited opportunities, his market value could diminish by the end of the season. For a young player looking to cash in, that’s a risky proposition.
The Clock Is Ticking
As NFL free agency heats up and draft preparations intensify, the Steelers will need to decide quickly how they want to handle the Pickens situation. Whether it’s a trade, an extension, or a one-year rental before parting ways, the decision will have a significant impact not only on the Steelers’ offense but also on the trajectory of George Pickens’ career.
For now, the football world watches and waits—wondering whether Pickens will remain a Steeler or find new life in another uniform.
