Emmy predictions full of surprises
As Emmy nomination voting closed on June 23, TV insiders and critics across the globe submitted their final ballots. While the frontrunners dominate headlines, there’s always room for surprises, the kind that makes you cheer from your lounge as your favourite dark horse sneaks into the nominations. This year, the underdogs are more compelling than ever, and one particular contender has fans rallying for overdue recognition: Matlock.
Yes, Matlock. The beloved courtroom drama has returned with a fresh face and a sharp new perspective, and it’s high time the Emmys took notice.
Kathy Bates stars alongside Jason Ritter, Leah Lewis, David Del Rio, and Skye P. Marshall in the 2024 version of Matlock. [Source: IMDb]
The curious case of Matlock and Emmy bias
Kathy Bates steps into the role of Madeline Matlock, a reimagining of the iconic character originally portrayed by Andy Griffith. With her razor-sharp delivery, steel-trap logic, and no-nonsense style, Bates breathes new life into the character. Her performance balances grit with charm, and the new Matlock smartly blends old-school courtroom storytelling with modern social commentary.
However, the show faces an uphill battle with Emmy voters who often overlook procedural dramas on traditional networks like CBS. As Gold Derby editor Debra Birnbaum noted, Matlock might help break that cycle: “A case Kathy Bates’ Matlock may well solve.”
The snubbing of procedural dramas isn’t new, but it’s increasingly outdated. Shows like Poker Face and The Residence have carved out space in awards conversations. So why not Matlock? The reboot offers all the narrative depth, moral complexity, and character-driven drama that award voters typically seek, just without the streaming platform.
Kathy Bates deserves her spotlight
Kathy Bates is no stranger to critical acclaim, but her work in Matlock demands fresh recognition. Her portrayal of the seasoned attorney is fierce yet empathetic, calculated but never cold. She makes legal arguments gripping, and emotional stakes feel tangible. Emmy voters often reward actors for bold choices and emotional range; Bates delivers both.
This role is more than just another courtroom gig. It’s a commentary on age, experience, and justice in a modern American landscape. Matlock reminds viewers that wisdom doesn’t fade with age; it sharpens. Bates embodies that wisdom with elegance and authority, earning every beat of applause she receives.
Why Matlock Matters in 2025
The reboot doesn’t just rest on nostalgia; it confronts contemporary issues head-on. From corporate misconduct to systemic bias in the legal system, Matlock handles its cases with nuance and clarity. The writing team manages to remain faithful to the spirit of the original while crafting a show that feels relevant in 2025.
TV procedurals often get dismissed as formulaic, but Matlock proves that solid structure can still deliver meaningful stories. That formula enables the show to delve deeply into character, ethics, and justice without unnecessary filler. It’s procedural television at its most refined.
A strong supporting case
Matlock also boasts a compelling supporting cast and guest stars that elevate each episode. Similar to Elsbeth, another CBS series with Emmy buzz, the chemistry between recurring characters and episodic guests brings rich variety to the show’s universe. Like Carrie Preston in Elsbeth, Kathy Bates commands each scene with charisma, intellect, and timing that few can rival.
Moreover, both series challenge the notion that CBS content is somehow less “prestige” than its streaming counterparts. As Matlock continues to garner a loyal audience and positive critical response, it earns its place in the Emmy conversation.
The time is right for recognition.
As we await the official nominations on July 15, we’re crossing our fingers for the unexpected — the kind of bold, refreshing inclusion that reinvigorates the Emmys. Matlock might not be the loudest campaign in town, but it’s one of the most deserving. The reboot showcases sharp storytelling, a towering central performance, and a modern edge that separates it from the crowd.
Award shows often miss the mark when they ignore network gems in favour of buzz-heavy prestige dramas. In 2025, it’s time to change that narrative. Let Matlock surprise us. Let Kathy Bates take the stage. And let justice — and good television — finally be served.
