A wave of dark curiosity has swept across eBay as sellers list bizarre memorabilia tied to accused Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann, igniting a firestorm among collectors and true crime enthusiasts. From a Vietnam-era military Jeep to yearbooks, fence pieces, and newspaper covers, items allegedly connected to Heuermann are drawing attention—and high bids.
Rex Heuermann, the accused Gilgo Beach serial killer, faces charges for the murders of seven sex workers on Long Island. [Credit: Newsday]
Bidding War over Rex Heuermann’s Army Jeep
One of the hottest items up for grabs is a 1972 US Army Jeep, previously owned by Rex Heuermann, currently fetching over $5,100 with six days left in the auction. The vehicle comes bundled with a trailer, hard and soft tops, and additional parts. The ad boasts that the Jeep has racked up over 522,000 miles and comes with all necessary registration documents.
[Source: Eyewitness News]
“The owner was none other than, The Long Island Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann,” the eBay listing reads. “Mr. Heuermann and family are featured in an original Peacock documentary that premiered June 10, 2025, The Gilgo Beach Killer – House of Secrets streaming on Peacock.”
While the concept of profiting from tragedy remains controversial, the seller insists all proceeds from the Jeep’s sale will go to Asa Ellerup, Heuermann’s ex-wife. Her attorney, Robert Macedonio, confirmed the arrangement to Eyewitness News.
“If you’re a true crime buff,” the listing teases, “this Jeep and trailer have quite a history.”
The Rise of ‘Murderabilia’ in the Rex Heuermann Case
True crime culture has long been drawn to what’s become known as “murderabilia”—collectibles tied to violent criminals. The case of Rex Heuermann, a Long Island architect accused of seven gruesome murders, has only intensified this niche interest.
Sellers have listed Heuermann’s 1977 McKenna Junior High School yearbook for $995, pieces of his fence accompanied by certificates of authenticity, and even a New York Post cover from January 17, 2024, for $11.33.
Memorabilia collector David Adamovich, who has distanced himself from the online auctions, told Newsday, “This is a big deal. Especially here on Long Island. A large collectible, like a jeep, it’s an interesting item.”
Public Fascination with the Gilgo Beach Murders
Heuermann’s arrest on July 13, 2023, shook Long Island. The 61-year-old stands accused of murdering seven sex workers over nearly three decades. Authorities linked him to the “Gilgo Four”—Amber Lynn Costello, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes—whose remains were found in 2010 near Gilgo Beach.
By January 2024, prosecutors added charges in the murders of Valerie Mack, Jessica Taylor, and Sandra Costilla, the earliest known victim, killed in 1993. While Karen Vergata’s death remains unlinked to Heuermann, her name often surfaces in media reports covering the case.
Heuermann has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Docuseries Fuels Market Demand
The case gained renewed attention with the launch of The Gilgo Beach Killer – House of Secrets, a three-part NBC/Peacock docuseries that premiered in June 2025. The series includes never-before-seen interviews with Asa Ellerup and their daughter, Victoria Heuermann, adding a deeply personal dimension to the public’s obsession.
As the documentary reignites national interest, the demand for associated memorabilia grows stronger.
Experts Weigh In
Andy Kahan, who leads victim services at Crime Stoppers Houston, weighed in on the disturbing trend: “I’ve been dealing with the ‘murderabilia’ industry for over 20-some odd years, and one thing I’ve learned is that when someone is attached or charged with serial killings, items will be put up for sale.”
According to Kahan, cases like Rex Heuermann’s often lead to surges in online auctions featuring items that collectors perceive as rare or morbidly valuable.
From Crime Scene to eBay Listings
Beyond the Jeep and yearbook, online listings include:
- Fence pieces from Heuermann’s Massapequa Park property
- Magazine and newspaper covers chronicling the investigation
- Maps of the Gilgo Beach area
- Quickie books summarizing the case’s developments
While some view these items as collectible history, others see them as exploitive and distasteful.
Also Read: Image of Alleged Offender Joshua Brown Emerged: Horrifying Details of Childcare Abuse
A Market Fueled by Morbid Curiosity
With nearly 900 views and 30 bids on the Jeep alone in just 24 hours, it’s clear that public curiosity about Rex Heuermann remains at a peak. The fascination with murderabilia shows no signs of slowing, especially as the case continues to evolve and receive national media coverage.
Whether this market crosses ethical lines or simply reflects society’s interest in true crime, the Rex phenomenon continues to stir debate—and generate revenue—online.
