Newsmax has filed an antitrust lawsuit against Fox News and its parent company, Fox Corporation. The case was filed in the Southern District of Florida and alleges anti-competitive exclusionary acts engaged by Fox. Newsmax claims that such tactics prevented the smaller network from competing on an equitable basis in gaining distribution and visibility.
The lawsuit states that Fox violated the dominant position in the conservative TV arena to restrain Newsmax’s growth. Newsmax executives contend that Fox applied pressure to distributors to force them to avoid or demote Newsmax’s carriage; in effect, this action would guarantee that Fox would remain the leading right-leaning voice on cable news.
The complaint is one of the bigger challenges to the longstanding dominance of Fox in the market for conservative media. It also points to the resentments that grew after the 2020 election, a time when Newsmax briefly experienced something of a surge in visibility.
Newsmax sues Fox News and Fox Corp in an antitrust case
How Does Newsmax Claim The Fox News Monopoly Impacts The Market?
Newsmax says consumers’ choice is limited under the “monopoly” that Fox News enjoys, and hence competition is lessened. In some of these carriage deals, distributors were allegedly coerced into signing carriage agreements in favour of Fox News and against its competitors. Also, Newsmax said that it was pushed into higher subscription tiers in some states, hence limiting the ability of viewers to access and view it.
The complaint reveals how the alleged conduct by Fox has been detrimental to smaller conservative outlets. Because it is considered a must-carry channel, Fox used its market power to set the terms with the distributors. According to Newsmax, that created a market where only Fox was able to retain its dominant voice.
Put in view of customers, this alleged monopoly means fewer choices within the sphere of conservative commentary. According to Newsmax, viewers who want to hear alternatives to the right are curtailed in their choices and are also barred from being exposed to competing voices.
Is Newsmax Seeking Damages In The Newsmax Fox Lawsuit?
Yes. Newsmax seeks treble damages under federal antitrust laws. With treble damages, plaintiffs can claim damages triple the amount of their actual calculated losses. Newsmax is seeking an injunction from enforcing exclusionary contracts against Fox.
Newsmax’s lawyers think the damages could be huge. Newsmax suggests it’s been losing advertising revenue and market share for years, with its distribution suppressed. It maintains that this suit is not just one for damages, but rather about restoring marketplace justice.
Fox News denies any wrongdoing. A Fox spokesperson disparaged the suit as meritless and argued that Newsmax is filing suit now because it can’t compete on its own merits.
Newsmax demands treble damages under federal antitrust law
What Evidence Does Newsmax Cite Against Fox?
The lawsuit refers to documents obtained in prior litigation against Fox concerning defamation. Internal emails and text records about Fox executives and anchors expressing grave apprehension about Newsmax were included. Newsmax saw rising viewership with election results doubters after the 2020 presidential elections.
Fox talent allegedly called Newsmax’s ascent “devastating” and strategised on how to retain top status. According to Newsmax, these documents show a pattern of trembling fear followed by knee-jerk reactions with Fox. Such proof, it states, supports allegations of Fox’s deliberate efforts to suppress competition.
Did Fox Respond To The Antitrust Claim?
Indeed, Fox was quick to respond, dismissing the lawsuit as a distraction. Company representatives claimed that Newsmax has been struggling to maintain relevance and viewership. They characterised the lawsuit as a publicity stunt rather than a legitimate legal claim.
Also, Fox reiterated that carriage agreements are common industry practices. They said that the Network competes fairly in a competitive cable news market. Fox said that Newsmax’s problems stem not from exclusion but inability to draw a consistent audience.
Fox swiftly dismissed the lawsuit as a mere distraction
Can This Case Reshape Conservative Media?
There could be a lot of consequences for conservative media. In case of a successful recount by Newsmax, distributors may have to begin, at least in part, adjusting their treatment of smaller networks. This could really widen the marketplace for alternative outlets of conservatism.
The lawsuit comes in an extremely complicated area of antitrust laws in the media. But Newsmax winning would provide a precedent for future claims against the big broadcasters-and it might put pressure even on Fox to reconsider its arrangements with the carriers.
For the viewers, this suit raises questions regarding the diversity of choice because if distributors are required to provide fairer access, audiences may thus be rewarded with a greater variety of conservative news coverage.
Contextual Landscape: Why Now?
The case is being initiated after a turbulent period in conservative broadcasting. In April 2023, Fox News paid Dominion Voting Systems $787.5 million in settlement of a suit by Dominion alleging that election fraud claims made by Fox hosts were false.
Newsmax was sued for similar allegations of defamation. It settled for $67 million with Dominion and another $40 million with Smartmatic. Both cases forced the networks to produce internal documents, revealing strategies in dealing with the competition and retention of audiences.
These high-profile legal disputes reshaped capital markets and reputation landscapes for the conservative broadcasters. For Newsmax, thus, the antitrust suit represents a challenge as well as a strategic opportunity. In seeking to enhance its own position within an evolving marketplace, Newsmax works against Fox.
Also Read: 12 Best Business News Podcasts in 2025 to Stay Ahead of Markets
FAQs
Q1: What caused Newsmax to sue?
Newsmax alleges that Fox News, by corrupting the exercise of market dominance, tried through intimidation of distributors and anticompetitive conduct to restrict competition in the area of conservative pay-TV news.
Q2: What damage does Newsmax seek?
Treble damages and an injunction against Fox enforcing exclusionary carriage contracts.
Q3: What evidence is offered?
Internal communications within Fox, admitted into evidence in a prior lawsuit, demonstrated that Fox executives feared the rise of Newsmax after the 2020 election.
Q4: What is Fox’s defence?
Fox denies the allegations, calling the suit meritless and claiming that Newsmax is just suffering from poor ratings.
